Tigraine

Daniel Hoelbling-Inzko talks about programming

Troublesome testing

Posted by Daniel Hölbling on May 21, 2009

This may be the very first time I blog about a bug in the CLR, but it’s annoying nonetheless.

Apparently a bug in the CLR’s System.Reflection.Emit prevents Rhino.Mocks from working when generic constraints are applied to a method.

void Add<T, TType>()
    where T : class
    where TType : T;

As long as the TType : T constraints is present, all tests will fail with a System.BadImageFormatException.
Now, the bug is known and it looks like it can’t really be helped on the framework side. But, I didn’t want to drop this constraint in my production code just to make the class testable.

So, I went back to the dark ages and actually wrote a Mock class by hand that counted calls to methods, returned preset values for methods.

Overall, the Mock is a mess. There are like 5-6 fields counting all sorts of different stuff just for a simple interface with two methods.

Thank god there are tools like Rhino.Mock that keep me from writing code like that (I really can’t praise Ayende enough for Rhino.Mocks).

Filed under net, testing
comments powered by Disqus

My Photography business

Projects

dynamic css for .NET

Archives

more